top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • LinkedIn
  • icons8-substack-24
  • Bluesky--Streamline-Simple-Icons
Search

A Federal Appeals Court Just Said the Quiet Part Out Loud: Agencies Have to Follow Their Own Rule

USAID Employee Support Fund
Jul 3
3 min read


Last week, the Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals handed down a ruling that career federal employees everywhere should know about, even if it did not happen in our case.


On July 2, 2026, in Doe v. Office of the Director of National Intelligence, the court affirmed a preliminary injunction protecting nineteen career intelligence officers at the CIA and ODNI. These were career employees, most of them only temporarily assigned to diversity and inclusion roles, who were told they would be terminated with no chance to seek reassignment or appeal, even though the agencies' own regulations promised both.


The agencies argued they had unlimited discretion to fire whoever they wanted, whenever they wanted, for whatever reason. The court agreed that discretion is real. But it drew a sharp line. Once an agency writes a rule that says employees get to ask for reassignment, or get to appeal, that rule creates a right the government cannot simply ignore. As the majority put it, an agency cannot fail to follow its own procedures and then use that failure as an excuse to avoid its obligations going forward.


That is not a partisan idea. It is one of the oldest ideas in administrative law. Agencies write rules. Agencies have to live by them. The court reached back to a 1954 Supreme Court case, Accardi v. Shaughnessy, and to core due process principles that predate any single administration, to say that government by rulebook still means something.


Courtroom table and chairs

Why This Matters to Us

Our own case, the consolidated MSPB appeal representing hundreds of separated USAID employees, sits on very similar ground. Our people were also career civil servants. They were also told the rules that were supposed to protect them simply did not apply anymore. And they are also fighting to establish that when an agency writes down a process, career employees are entitled to that process, not as a courtesy, but as a matter of law.

This ruling is not our case, and every case stands on its own facts. There was also a strong dissent, and the losing side has real arguments left to make on appeal. Legal fights like this one are rarely settled after a single ruling. But when a federal appeals court affirms that agencies do not get to write rights into a regulation and then pretend those rights do not exist the moment they become inconvenient, that strengthens the ground under every career employee still fighting for the same thing. It is a reminder that due process and merit-system protections are not relics. They are enforceable.


A Familiar Face in the Fight

Our own litigation counsel, Kevin Byrnes, was part of the legal team on this case, working alongside Kevin Carroll and Kia Rahnama. Kevin previously worked with the firm that argued the appeal, and he brought that background to bear here. Watching him help win a real, tangible victory for career employees in another agency is a good reminder of why we do this work. The same principles, the same cases every day.


Classroom with USAID-branded chairs

The Bigger Picture

Cases like this one add up. Every ruling that reaffirms due process protections for career employees, regardless of which agency, which administration, or which political moment produced the dispute, builds the body of law that people like our plaintiffs are relying on. Merit-system integrity is not a Democratic value or a Republican value. It is the foundation that lets people build careers in public service without wondering if the rules will simply vanish overnight.


We will keep watching cases like this one and keep fighting ours.


They wrote the obituary too early. USAID lives.



 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page