top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • LinkedIn
  • icons8-substack-24
  • Bluesky--Streamline-Simple-Icons
Search

The Government Can't Keep Its Own Story Straight

USAID Employee Support Fund
Jul 1
3 min read



"The chaotic and illegal destruction of United States Agency for International Development (USAID) was the bureaucratic equivalent of the issues facing the botched modifications of the Lincoln Memorial Reflecting Pool; it was based on personal whim, was chaotic, produced harmful results, and cost the American taxpayers millions of dollars because it was ill-conceived, based on false premises and done with a mixture of incompetence and cynical disdain."


That is the opening line of our opposition to the government's motion to dismiss in Greene, et al. v. USAID, et al., filed in federal court on June 30. The case centers on three career employees, with a combined 43 years of public service between them, who worked in USAID's Civil Rights office. Their job was straightforward: help the agency comply with civil rights law and support minority-serving institutions, work that both the Biden and the first Trump administrations had directed federal agencies to do. For that work, they were told they were "radical lunatics" and part of "a criminal organization”, placed on leave, and terminated.


The agencies can't agree on who did what

Here is where it gets telling. The government's own motion to dismiss argues that everyone except USAID itself should be let off the hook for terminating these employees. It says that the Office of Personnel Management, the Office of Management and Budget, and the State Department weren't close enough to what happened to be sued over it.

But our filing lays out the government's own paper trail:

  • OPM issued the memo that started it all, ordering every federal agency to place DEIA staff on leave and close their offices. OPM has since told the Merit Systems Protection Board it is taking over USAID's defense in this very case, effectively standing in as USAID.

  • DOGE, whose legal authority to do any of this remains genuinely unclear even to the administration itself, is the entity that actually locked employees out of their offices and systems, according to public reporting cited in the case.

  • OMB, working alongside OPM, DOGE, and USAID, helped strip these employees of their duties and system access before they had even been told why.

  • The State Department absorbed USAID and recreated some of the same positions that had just been eliminated.


You can't have it both ways. OPM can't tell one court it had nothing to do with these firings while telling another court it's now standing in for USAID, the very agency it claims no connection to. Our filing makes that contradiction impossible to ignore.




Why this matters beyond one case

This isn't about partisanship. It's about whether a federal job can be taken away because of who holds power, rather than how well someone does the work.


Our filing puts the stakes in stark terms. This case raises one fundamental question: does the Civil Service Reform Act, the law passed to build a meritorious public service, free of political partisanship and patronage, still govern federal employment? Or have federal workers quietly become "at-will" servants of whoever occupies the White House, who can be fired not for poor performance but for being perceived as disloyal to the person or party in power?


The answer matters far beyond USAID. A merit-based civil service exists so that the government keeps functioning no matter who wins an election, so public servants can do their jobs without fear of being purged for their politics, and so institutional knowledge built over decades doesn't walk out the door with every change of administration. Gut that protection, and you don't just lose good people. You open the door to a spoils system where loyalty outranks competence, where every incoming administration cleans house regardless of merit, and where the next generation of talented people thinks twice before choosing public service at all.


If the Civil Service Reform Act still means what Congress wrote it to mean, cases like this one should move forward and these employees should get their day in court. If it doesn't, then the merit-based system that has protected American governance for nearly half a century is, as our filing puts it, extinct.


We'll keep you posted as the court rules. In the meantime, the record keeps growing, and it keeps confirming what we've said from the start.


They wrote the obituary too early. USAID lives.


Read the full filing on CourtListener: Greene v. USAID, et al., No. 1:25-cv-04217 (D.D.C.)

Support the legal fight: usaidemployeefund.org/get-involved

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page