top of page
  • Black Facebook Icon
  • Black Instagram Icon
  • LinkedIn
  • icons8-substack-24
  • Bluesky--Streamline-Simple-Icons
Search

The Court Just Rewrote the Rules for Independent Agencies. Public Servants Are Next in Line

USAID Employee Support Fund
Jul 7
3 min read

Last Monday, the Supreme Court decided a case about five commissioners at the Federal Trade Commission. The ruling will not stop there. It reaches the two million career civil servants who keep this country running, and it puts pressure on workplace protections that private-sector employees have counted on for generations.



The case is Trump v. Slaughter, decided June 29 by a vote of six to three. The Court held that Congress cannot require a president to show cause before removing commissioners of the Federal Trade Commission, and in doing so, it overturned Humphrey’s Executor v. United States, the unanimous 1935 decision that served for ninety-one years as the legal foundation for independent agencies. Chief Justice John Roberts left no room for a narrow reading: “If anything more is left of Humphrey’s, we overrule it.”


Congress built dozens of agencies on the foundation that the Court just removed. It was built so that certain decisions would be made by experts applying the law, insulated from the political pressures of the moment. That design is now in question across the government.

There is no referee on the court.
There is no referee on the court.

The part that should worry every public servant

Justice Sonia Sotomayor read her dissent from the bench, something justices do only when they believe a decision is gravely wrong. Her list of agencies whose independence is now in doubt includes the Merit Systems Protection Board.


Most Americans have never heard of it. Every federal employee knows it well. When a career employee believes they were unlawfully fired, demoted, or punished, their appeal goes to the Board. It has one job: to decide those cases on the law and the facts, not on politics.


A sitting Supreme Court justice, describing where this decision could lead, wrote that civil service employment protections may cease to exist. That sentence should be on the front page of every newspaper in the country. It wasn’t.



The practical problem is simple. If the Board’s own members serve at the pleasure of the administration, whose personnel decisions they review, the appeal process changes character. The referee is still on the field, but one team can send the referee home at any time. And the Board will be the first body to apply this ruling to real cases involving real employees, including the question of which civil servants still hold removal protections at all.


Why private-sector workers should care

The same reasoning that led the Federal Trade Commission to act applies to the National Labor Relations Board, which protects the right of private-sector workers to organize and bargain without retaliation. Within days of the ruling, labor law analysts concluded that the removal protections for that board’s members are no longer enforceable.


There is also a longer story here. Protections won by public servants have set the floor for everyone else for more than a century. The merit system, created in 1883, introduced the then-radical idea that a job should depend on your work rather than your politics. Due process for government workers came first. Fair-dismissal norms were followed in the private sector. When the floor under public servants drops, it drops under every American worker. That is not a partisan claim. It is how labor standards have always moved in this country, in both directions.


What this means for our case

The USAID Employee Support Fund funds the legal fight of hundreds of career employees separated from their agency, a fight now before a federal appeals court that has agreed to review the case in full.


We will be straight with you about last week. The government has argued throughout this litigation that the Constitution gives the president broad authority over executive branch personnel, and the Slaughter decision strengthens that argument. Anyone who tells you otherwise is not reading the opinion.


But the headlines missed something. The Court went out of its way to say what it was not deciding. It expressly declined to address tenure protections for officers who perform judicial functions, leaving “those questions for another day.” The same day, in a companion case, it blocked the removal of a Federal Reserve governor. Presidential removal power still has limits that the Court is prepared to enforce.


Our case does not ask any court to save a commissioner’s job. It asks an older question: when the government separates career employees, must it follow the procedures its own laws and regulations require? The Court did not answer that question last week because it was never asked. Our plaintiffs are carrying it forward. And when the independence of the institutions is in doubt, the rules themselves are what remain. Someone has to stand up in court and insist they still apply.


That is what these career employees are doing. Slow, expensive work, and the only way worker rights have ever been secured in this country: one case at a time.


They wrote the obituary too early. USAID lives.


Support the legal fight at usaidemployeefund.org/get-involved.

 
 
 

Comments


bottom of page